In this article
How to Cook

Party Appetizers & Holiday Entertaining: Complete Guide to Stress-Free Hosting

Published Updated 9 min read

Most of a holiday party spread can be bought: a tray from our deli, a few boxes from the frozen aisle and ready-made dips, plus one or two dishes you make at home. Start by counting your guests and deciding whether appetizers are the whole meal. Then order deli trays at least 48 hours ahead, make cold dishes the day before, and keep food out no more than 2 hours.

For cooking warm dips and oven or air fryer bites, see our Holiday Appetizers & Party Starters guide. What we offer, lead times, pickup, and delivery vary by store, so please check with your local store.

Quick reference

Appetizers before dinnerabout 6 pieces per person, 2 or 3 kinds
Appetizers as the mealabout 12 pieces per person
How fast guests eatabout 5 pieces in the first hour, then about 3 an hour
How many kinds3 for 8 to 10 guests; 4 or 5 for 14 to 16
Deli party trays48 hours to prepare; please check with your local store
Bakery cookie tray / cupcakes48 hours / 24 hours
New Year's Eve tray pickup Thu Dec 31order by Tue Dec 29
Food out at room temperature2 hours max in total (1 hour above 90°F)
Hot food on the buffet140°F or warmer
Cold food on the buffet40°F or colder
Reheating165°F

How Many Appetizers per Person

Before a sit-down dinner, plan on about 6 pieces per person in 2 or 3 kinds, or about 12 pieces per person when appetizers are the meal at a cocktail party, open house, or New Year's Eve party. Plan more if the party runs long or your guests are big eaters. Guests eat about 5 pieces each in the first hour, then about 3 an hour, so a 4-hour party for 10 is about 14 pieces each (5 + 3 + 3 + 3), or about 140 pieces in all.

Serve about 3 kinds for 8 to 10 guests, 4 or 5 for 14 to 16, and about 6 for up to 45, dividing the total pieces by the number of kinds. A dip or tray counts toward the total, not on top of it, and a frozen box lists its piece count or servings on the package. These counts are a rule of thumb: published party guides range from 8 to 20 pieces per person when appetizers replace dinner.

Ordering Our Deli Party Trays

Our deli makes sandwich trays, fruit trays, vegetable and dip trays, and wing trays to order, and each tray takes 48 hours to prepare, so order at least 2 days before pickup. To order online, go to our catering page, sign in, choose your store, add the tray, and pick a pickup or delivery time at least 48 hours away. Our bakery takes orders the same way: a 48-count cookie tray needs 48 hours, and 24-count cupcakes need 24 hours.

For Christmas Eve pickup on Thursday, December 24, order by Tuesday, December 22; for New Year's Eve pickup on Thursday, December 31, order by Tuesday, December 29, at the same time of day as the pickup or earlier. What we offer, sizes, pickup, and delivery vary by store, so please check with your local store. Too late to order? A packaged veggie tray with ranch dip is ready to take home from our produce section.

Frozen Appetizers for a Party

Pick frozen appetizers by who is coming: cheesy bites like mozzarella sticks and pizza rolls for kids, wings or loaded potato skins for a game-day crowd, and spring rolls for a guest who eats vegan or gluten-free. Our frozen aisle has mozzarella sticks, cheese and pepperoni pizza rolls, loaded potato skins, cheese and bacon mini quiche, pork potstickers, spring rolls, and bone-in buffalo wings. The Lucky spring rolls are labeled certified gluten-free and certified vegan, with no MSG.

Buy boxes a week or two ahead while the shelves are full, and check each package for the piece count, servings, and cooking directions. Cook them from frozen in the oven or air fryer as the package directs. If oven space is short, cook in batches through the party instead of all at once.

When you are short on time, a couple of frozen boxes and a deli tray cover a party; for a sit-down meal, see our Thanksgiving dinner guide for ready-to-heat holiday dinners. Trays and dinners vary by store, so please check with your local store.

Store-Bought Plus a Few Homemade Dips

Buy the things that take the most work, including trays, frozen bites, chips, and crackers, and make one or two dips at home. Put each dip out in a small bowl and keep a second bowl in the fridge. Swap them before the first has been out 2 hours in total, or 1 hour above 90°F.

Ready-made dips

Our deli and chip aisle have ready-made spinach artichoke dip, French onion dip, hummus, guacamole, and chunky salsa. The spinach artichoke dip is gluten-free.

Homemade dips

Most of our dip recipes below take 10 to 20 minutes. For a big crowd, the 6-Layer Light Mexican Dip serves 15.

Boards and Platters

A board is mostly things you buy at our deli, put together on a platter. For a big crowd, the Charcuterie Bouquet by Sargento®, with salami and cheese roses, serves 20. A Dessert Charcuterie Board works for the end of the night.

Build two smaller boards and keep one in the fridge. Bring out the second and take away the first before it has been out 2 hours in total, or 1 hour above 90°F.

Shrimp Cocktail

Buy shrimp that is already cooked, peeled, and deveined so there is nothing to cook. Our Waterfront Bistro shrimp comes that way with its own cocktail sauce, or you can buy cooked shrimp on its own and pick up a bottle of cocktail sauce. What the seafood counter has varies by store; please check with your local store.

Thaw and store it as the package directs, and keep it at 40°F or colder by setting the bowl or platter in a larger bowl of ice. For something warm, the Spicy Shrimp Dip serves 12.

What to Do Ahead, and When

A week or two ahead, buy frozen appetizers, crackers, chips, jarred salsa and cocktail sauce. At least 2 days ahead, order deli and bakery trays; please check with your local store. The day before, make cold dips and anything that needs to chill, checking each recipe for how far ahead it can be made.

Anything you cook ahead goes in the fridge within 2 hours of cooking and keeps 3 to 4 days. On the day, pick up the trays, heat frozen appetizers in batches, and set food out a little at a time. For a big group, the Hot Broccoli and Cheese Dip serves 24.

A slow cooker serves a crowd and frees the oven. Start the Slow Cooker Sweet & Sour Cocktail Meatballs about 4 hours before you want to serve them. For meatballs from the package, heat them in sauce on the stove to 165°F, then move them to a slow cooker to keep warm. Do not heat cold meatballs in the slow cooker; it heats too slowly to bring cold food to a safe temperature.

Keeping a Buffet Safe

Before guests arrive, reheat cooked food, including egg dishes such as quiche, to 165°F, checking with a food thermometer, not the oven setting. Set out several small platters instead of one big one, and keep the rest hot in the oven or cold in the fridge until it is needed.

Keep hot food at 140°F or warmer in a chafing dish, slow cooker or warming tray. Some warmers only reach 110°F to 120°F, so check the label. Keep cold food at 40°F or colder by setting the dishes in bowls of ice. When a platter runs low, replace it with a fresh one instead of adding new food to a dish that has been sitting out.

Throw out perishable food that has been out at room temperature more than 2 hours, or 1 hour if the room or outdoors is above 90°F, unless it is kept hot or cold. The 2 hours count all the time the food has been out; setting it back out does not start the count again.

A New Year's Eve Party

A party from 8 p.m. to past midnight runs 4 hours or more, so plan on the high count of about 5 pieces each in the first hour and about 3 an hour after. New Year's Eve 2026 is a Thursday, so order trays by Tuesday, December 29. Store hours on New Year's Eve and New Year's Day vary; please check with your local store.

Serve in rounds: put out one set of platters, take it away before it has been out 2 hours, and bring out the next. Save a hot round for late in the evening, such as the Baked Prosciutto-Wrapped Jalapeño Poppers, and pour the Sparkling Cranberry Punch at midnight; it serves 30.

Frequently asked questions

Can I order party trays from your deli, and how far ahead?

Yes, you can order sandwich, fruit, vegetable and dip, and wing trays at least 48 hours ahead on our catering page. Bakery cookie trays need 48 hours and cupcakes need 24 hours; please check with your local store.

How many appetizers do I need per person?

Plan on about 6 pieces per person before dinner and about 12 when appetizers are the meal. As a rule of thumb, guests eat about 5 pieces in the first hour, then about 3 an hour.

Which frozen appetizers are good for a party?

Pick by who is coming: mozzarella sticks or pizza rolls for kids, wings or potato skins for a game-day crowd, and Lucky spring rolls labeled certified gluten-free and vegan for those guests.

What are easy store-bought appetizers for a party?

Easy options include a deli tray, a frozen box or two, ready-made dips with chips, cooked shrimp with cocktail sauce, and a board put together from our deli.

How long can appetizers sit out?

Appetizers can sit out for 2 hours at room temperature in total, or 1 hour above 90°F.

How do I keep party food hot or cold?

Keep hot food at 140°F or warmer in a chafing dish, slow cooker, or warming tray, and cold food at 40°F or colder in bowls of ice. Use small platters and replace them rather than topping them up.

What party food can I make the day before?

Make cold dips and anything that chills the day before, and check each recipe for timing. Cooked food goes in the fridge within 2 hours and keeps 3 to 4 days.

How do I plan for guests with different diets?

Keep the packages or note what is in each dish so guests can read the label. The Lucky spring rolls are labeled certified gluten-free and vegan.